Comparative Demographic Traits of
the Whitefly (Bemisia tabaci) B Biotype against different Host Plants
Muhammad Farooq1, Muhammad
Shakeel2*, Umbreen Shahzad3, Bilal Saeed Khan4,
Muhammad Rafiq Shahid5, Faisal Hafeez5, Misbah Ashraf5
1School of Earth, Environment and Biological Sciences, Queensland
University of Technology, Brisbane, 4000, Australia,
2College of Agriculture, South China Agricultural University, Laboratory of
Bio-Pesticide Creation and Application of Guangdong Province, Guangzhou, P. R.
China,
3College of Agriculture, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan (Layyah Sub-Campus),
Pakistan,
4Department of Entomology, University of Agriculture, Faisalabad, 38000,
Pakistan
5Ayub Agricultural Research Institute, Faisalabad, Pakistan
*For correspondence: faizaneabiwaqas@scau.edu.cn; sanjum2005@gmail.com
Received 08 February 2020;
Accepted 02 May 2020; Published 10 January 2021
Abstract
The sucking pests, especially whitefly, have damaged
various fields and fruit crops across the globe. The study of life-history is
of prime importance to monitor the dynamics for preference of a species to its
host. This study tested the prevalence and preference of a whitefly species, Bemisia
tabaci (Gennadius) B biotype (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae) on tomato, cotton,
pepper, and okra as hosts using age-stage two-sex life table. Results revealed
the highest pre-adult developmental duration, survival rate, and fecundity on
tomato while the lowest values on okra. Population parameters such as the net
reproductive rate (R0), intrinsic rate of increase (r), and
finite rate of increase (λ) were
demonstrated longer on cotton and tomato compared to much lower R0, r,
and λ on pepper and okra. Okra
responded significantly differently in the case of the mean generation time, T
among all tested genotypes. These findings suggest the possibility of summer
vegetables as more favorable hosts for B. tabaci.
© 2021 Friends Science Publishers
Keywords: Host plants; Biology;
Fecundity; Longevity; Survival; Whitefly
Introduction
The whitefly, Bemisia tabaci B biotype
(Gennadius) (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae) have become a
significant pest for a wide range of agricultural and ornamental plants since
the last two decades (Oliveira et al. 2001; Naranjo et al. 2009).
The whitefly damages the crop in two ways; one by the nymphs by sucking cell
sap and producing honeydew; and the other by the transmission of various
viruses to other plants (Jones 2003; Naranjo et al. 2009). The females
lay eggs in the groups of 30–40 eggs in patches (Martin et al. 2000).
The first instar larvae move to short distances to acquire food sources, but
other instars are immobile and are stick to the leaf surface. Their abilities
of rapid development, high fecundity, and suitability to adverse living
conditions hinder the successful control (Barro et al. 2011; Lu et
al. 2012). The un-planned, unnoticed and rigorous use of insecticides has
not only created resistance against a broader range of pesticides but triggered
many health and environment-related problems. The previous studies only
reported the population abundance and management practices of lepidopterous
pests, neglected the population ecology of sucking pests (Men et al.
2005). As a result, sucking pests especially B. tabaci overwhelmed the
management tactics and became a member of the major pest complex (Wu et al.
2002; Akram et al. 2013). As a huge gap has been created, which needs to
be addressed by thoroughly understanding the behavior of sucking pests.
The
nutritional quality of the host affects the biological parameters of
polyphagous insect species (Askoul et al. 2018; Farooq et al.
2018, 2020). The developmental duration, fecundity, and longevity of B.
tabaci are also strongly influenced by the type of host plant with high
nutritional qualities, it provides more food, shelter, and space for
ovipositing (Lorenzo et al. 2016). Insects recognize the food quality of
a host plant through various stimuli that help to locate the host plants.
Different morphological leaf characters such as hair density, shape, and color
determine the attractiveness to a pest species (Oriani et al. 2011). The
nutritional effects of host plants in various species of whitefly have been
studied earlier but very little information is available about the life history
parameters of B. tabaci based on age-stage two-sex life table.
The
awareness about the life and biology of a pest is the crucial factor
determining its feeding potential. A pest behaves differently at each age and
stage in various environments or living conditions (Chi 1990). The
implementation of life tables offers a firm understanding of the developmental
and reproductive potential of a particular pest under changing living
conditions that can be implied in the manipulation of future management
strategies (Musa and Ren 2005). Most of the studies utilized traditional
female-specific life tables (Birch 1948; Khan et al. 2017) to generate
life tables of insect pests under different environmental situations. A
female-specific life table does not provide an accurate picture of the
population projection of an insect by neglecting the contribution of males and
stages in population growth (Birch 1948). The most advanced form of life table
is the age-stage two-sex life table developed by Chi (1988) and Chi and Liu
(1985) which considers stage differentiation and offers a nearly appropriate
estimate of the future population in varying conditions. Unfortunately, the use
of the age-stage two-sex life table remained underemphasized to study the
biology of sucking pests due to inappropriate handling of a large amount and
misinterpretation of data (Samih et al. 2014). Awareness on a large
scale is needed to encourage scientists to use advances tools while studying
population ecology.
The present
studies were aimed to investigate the possibilities of the success of B.
tabaci on different host plants by taking into account the developmental
duration, fecundity, and life table parameters with the help of age-stage
two-sex life table. This study considered tomato, cotton, pepper, and okra
genotypes to compare the success of B. tabaci and also performed a
population projection analysis to evaluate the future population potential
within the specified time.
Materials and Methods
Host
plants and Bemisia tabaci culture
Four different host plants (tomato, cotton, pepper, and okra) were used
in these experiments. The 30 seeds of each genotype were sown in 120 plant pots
having 25 cm diameter filled with compost and perlite substrate and placed
under glasshouse conditions (25 ± 3°C, 60 ± 5 R. H. and photoperiod 16: 8 h L: D) (Azimi et al.
2013). Forty pairs of wild B.
tabaci adults were initially collected with an aspirator from
research farms of Ayub Agricultural Research Institute, Faisalabad, Pakistan
and released onto host plants at 4–5 leaf stage
placed in a cubic cage (30 x 30 x 30 cm3) covered with a fine mesh
net (Guo et al. 2014). The plants were watered and fertilized regularly
throughout the study period for their proper growth. Three generations of B. tabaci were raised on each of the tested host plants under the same conditions before
being used for experimentation and to reduce the effect of wild hosts.
Life table studies
For assessing developmental duration, 1-day old adults collected from
culture were shifted on a potted plant placed under the same lab conditions.
After 24 h, the leaves were turned to observe eggs with a 10X hand lens, and
adults were removed. A total cohort of 50 eggs was used per treatment. Each egg
was circled with the help of a fine non-toxic marker, and all other eggs on
leaves were gently removed to maintain the purity of marked leaves. The maximum
of five leaves was retained on one plant, each leaf having one egg.
Small-numbered tags were hanged around the leaf petiole to indicate each
treatment. The same procedure was repeated for first instar nymphs soon after
they settled on the leaf. After the establishment of the first-instar nymph on
the leaf, nymphs do not move until the emergence of adults. Moulting and
development of each nymph were observed daily with a 10 X hand lens. The leaves
were detached at the pupal stage and shifted to plastic cages (13 cm × 3 cm)
covered with a fine mesh net. After the adults’ emergence, both sexes were
observed daily for oviposition and longevity studies.
Statistical analysis
The data were analyzed using the TWOSEX-MSChart (Chi 2013). The bootstrap technique with 100,000
replications was applied for the estimation of mean and standard errors for each treatment (Efron and Tibshirani
1993). The Origin 2018 was used to draw the figures. The following
parameters were calculated according to respective equations.
The
age-specific survival rate (lx)
and age-specific fecundity (mx) were calculated as:
Where, k exhibits the number of stages.
The net reproductive rate (R0) was
computed as:
The intrinsic rate of increase (r) with age
indexed from 0 was corrected by the Euler-Lotka equation (Goodman 1982):
The following equation was used for the finite rate of
increase (λ):
The mean generation time was demonstrated as
The life
expectancy (exj) was determined as:
Where, siy shows the probability of
survival of each individual of age x and stage j to age i and
stage y by assuming sxj = 1.
The
reproductive rate (vxj)
was assessed according to (Tuan et al. 2014a, b).
Population projection and confidence interval
The population growth of B. tabaci on four different host plants was projected from life
table data based by the method of Chi and Liu (1985) and Chi (1990) using TIMING-MSChart (Chi 2017). The bootstrap method with 100,000 repeats
was used to determine the variability in population growth of life table
parameters. 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles were generated
by bootstrap for R0 and λ.
Results
Developmental time
The results revealed that the incubation period of B. tabaci significantly differed among
tested host plants (Table 1). The total pre-adult developmental duration was
noted significantly longer on okra than raised on other hosts, while shorter
pre-adult developmental duration was observed on tomato. The immature survival
rate was recorded higher on tomato and lowest on okra, which significantly
differed from other hosts. Female adult longevity remained the greatest on okra
and tomato, varying considerably from cotton and pepper. On the other hand,
male adult longevity was found to be the longest on tomato whereas the shortest
on okra. The results show that females live longer than males. The total
longevity on okra was found significantly higher than tested host plants. These
results express the suitability and unsuitability of B. tabaci on various host plants.
Fecundity and population growth parameters
The adult pre-ovipositional periods (APOP) and total
pre-ovipositional period (TPOP) (Table 1) were estimated significantly longer
on okra than other hosts. The feeding of B.
tabaci on different host plants reflects that the shortest oviposition
duration and the lowest fecundity were recorded on pepper and okra, and the
highest fecundity on tomato and cotton, respectively. The same trend was also
observed for daily-maximum and life-long fecundity. Based on the mean
comparison, results showed that tomato was more susceptible to B. tabaci than other hosts.
Age
stage-specific survival rate (sxj)
showed the probability for the survival of freshly laid eggs of B. tabaci to each age-stage unit (Fig.
1). The highest survival curve for adult female and male on each cultivar was
0.48 and 0.26 (cotton), 0.34 and 0.28 (pepper), 0.30 and 0.26 (okra), 0.46 and
0.4 (tomato). These values are statistically at par with pre-adult survival
rate (%) of 0.74, 0.62, 0.56 and 0.86 respectively (Table 1). The curves not
only explain the survivorship but also have overlapping curves showing stage
discrepancy, which is an important feature for insects (Fig. 1). The
consistency in data represents that adult B.
tabaci emerged earlier when reared on tomato and survives longer. The lx, mx and lxmx
for B. tabaci reared on each host
plant species showed that the highest peak of mx was noted on tomato at age of 28 d and the lowest
peak was on pepper at the age of 32 d (Fig. 2).
The age-stage
specific life expectancy (exj)
presents the expected life span of B.
tabaci on test hos plants (Fig. 3). The life expectancy of freshly laid
eggs on each host plant species was 27.06, 27.1, 27.76, and 27.92 d,
respectively which is precisely similar to mean longevity of the whole cohort
on each host species, respectively. Life expectancy (exj) was decreased with the advancement in age due to in
vitro condition which prevented the B.
tabaci from harsh environmental field conditions. The age-stage specific
reproductive value (vxj)
of B. tabaci illustrates the
contribution of individuals of age x
and stage j to the future population
(Fig. 4). The reproductive value of B.
tabaci at the egg stage was almost equal to the finite rate of increase in
each host species. The highest reproductive peak of females was observed on
tomato at the age of 20 d, while the reproductive peak for pepper was the
lowest and found at later age of 26 d. The lower reproductive peak on pepper
showed a moderate population increase.
The net
reproductive rate R0,
intrinsic rate of increase r, and
finite rate of increase λ
exhibited the lowest and mean generation time T the longest on okra (Table 2). Controversially, B. tabaci
reared on tomato revealed the highest R0,
r and λ and shortest T as
compared to other host plants.
Population projection and uncertainty
The population was projected highest on cotton and
expected to increase 25990.63 individuals at the age of 60, whereas okra
predicted the lowest population size of approximately 544.316 individuals at
the end of 60 d (Fig. 5). The variability in the total population size traced
at 60 d projected from the 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles of the Table 1: Developmental duration, longevity, and fecundity of Bemisia tabaci reared on different host
plant species
|
|
|
|
Host Plant Species |
|
|
|
|
Developmental duration (d) |
n |
Tomato |
n |
Cotton |
N |
Pepper |
n |
Okra |
Egg |
48 |
3.98 ±
0.11d |
46 |
5.04 ±
0.08c |
44 |
5.91 ±
0.11b |
45 |
6.49 ±
0.11a |
N1 |
47 |
3.43 ±
0.08c |
46 |
3.65 ±
0.07b |
41 |
3.66 ±
0.09b |
42 |
4.02 ±
0.11a |
N2 |
46 |
2.57 ±
0.07c |
44 |
2.68 ±
0.07c |
39 |
3.54 ±
0.08b |
40 |
3.8 ± 0.1a |
N3 |
45 |
2.42 ±
0.07d |
40 |
2.6 ± 0.08c |
36 |
3.56 ±
0.09b |
36 |
4.14 ±
0.12a |
Pupa |
43 |
3.47 ±
0.08c |
37 |
3.86 ±
0.14b |
31 |
5.61 ±
0.11a |
28 |
5.61 ±
0.17a |
Total
pre-adult |
43 |
15.88 ±
0.16d |
37 |
17.81 ±
0.21c |
31 |
22.35 ±
0.21b |
28 |
23.93 ±
0.33a |
Pre-adult
survival rate (%) |
|
0.86 |
|
0.74 |
|
0.62 |
|
0.56 |
Adult duration (d) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Female
adult longevity |
23 |
18.17 ±
0.29a |
24 |
17.62 ±
0.26b |
17 |
17.47 ±
0.21b |
15 |
18.2 ±
0.26a |
Male
adult longevity |
20 |
11.6 ±
0.23a |
13 |
10.31 ±
0.36b |
14 |
10.5 ±
0.25b |
13 |
9.38 ±
0.27c |
Total
longevity |
43 |
31.02 ±
0.49c |
37 |
32.86 ±
0.68b |
31 |
36.68 ±
0.72a |
28 |
38.04 ±
0.96a |
Fecundity |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
APOP |
|
2.78 ±
0.13b |
|
2.58 ±
0.1b |
|
2.29 ±
0.11c |
|
3.13 ±
0.17a |
TPOP |
|
18.26 ±
0.21d |
|
20.54 ±
0.31c |
|
24.82 ±
0.33b |
|
27.33 ±
0.51a |
Oviposition
days |
|
12.65 ±
0.23a |
|
12 ± 0.27b |
|
11.82 ±
0.27b |
|
11.73 ±
0.32b |
Fecundity
(nymphs/female) |
|
122.7 ±
2.74a |
|
115.21
± 1.79b |
|
60.12 ±
0.76d |
|
66.07 ±
2.16c |
Daily
maximum |
|
19 |
|
16 |
|
12 |
|
11 |
Life-long
maximum |
|
149 |
|
127 |
|
65 |
|
83 |
Where, N1= 1st Nymphal instar, N2= second
nymphal instar, N3= 3rd nymphal instar; TPOP=Total pre-ovipositional
period; APOP=Adult pre-ovipositional period. Values are mean ± S.E; Means
within rows followed by the same letter are not significantly different.
Standard errors were measured by 200,000 bootstrap resampling
Fig.
1:
Age-stage specific survival rate (sxj) of B. tabaci
reared on four host plant species
finite rate, and the net reproductive rate is
demonstrated (Fig. 6).
Discussion
Developmental and population parameters of insects are
affected by different biological, chemical, or physical traits such as plant
phenology and secondary compounds. The consumption potential of a pest is
generally evaluated by developmental or behavioral responses (Phelan et al.
1995; Awmack and Leather 2002; Lee 2007). The use of life tables in determining
these responses proved a useful tool to assess the relative acceptance or
rejection of host plants by an insect species. Age-stage, two-sex life table
has gained much insight among entomologists to evaluate the resistance of
different plant genotypes against insect pests and to forecast future pest
population peaks compared to female-specific life table (Morris and Miller
1954; Ying et al. 2012). This study also used the age-stage, two-sex
life table to assess the plant resistance in four different host plants against
B. tabaci.
Earlier researchers
have reported the effect of host plant species on the development, survival,
and fecundity of B. tabaci. The present study results demonstrated that
pre-adult developmental duration was shorter when B. tabaci reared on
tomato and cotton compared to other hosts. Statistical non-significant
differences in population growth of Bemisia argentifolii Bellows &
Perring were observed on cotton, cantaloupe, and pepper cultivars
(Nava-Camberos et al. 2001) whereas fluctuating differences were
observed when studying the population parameters of B. argentifolii on
two cultivars of hibiscus (Liu and Stansly 1998). The pre-adult development of B.
tabaci varied significantly among soybean, cowpea and garden bean (Musa and
Ren 2005). In another study, bean cultivars were found more resistant against
whitefly, Trialeurodes vaporariorum (West.) (Hemiptera - Homoptera:
Aleyrodidae) compared to soybean (Campos et al. 2003).
Fig. 2:
Age-specific survival rate (lx),
age-stage specific fecundity (fxj),
age-specific fecundity (mx)
and age-specific maternity (lxmx)
of B. tabaci reared on four host plant species
Fig.
3:
Age-stage specific life expectancy (exj) of B. tabaci reared on four host plant species
Life
history parameters of B. tabaci are affected by host quality, trichome
density, and nutritional value of host plants. Mostly, plant species with hairy
leaves are preferred by the insects for feeding and as a site for egg holding
(Butler et al. 1991; Mcauslane 1996). The resistant cultivars may
produce particular kinds of proteins or boost the chlorophyll content to avoid
the pest attack and triggering the resistance process (Smith 2005; Bernardi et
al. 2012). The present study results demonstrated that pre-adult mortality
percentage remained the highest on okra which depicts unfavorable population
growth for B. tabaci. Male, female and total longevities were found to
be significant among tested host species.
Table 2: Population growth
parameters of Bemisia tabaci on
different host plant species
Parameters |
|
Host plant Species |
|
|
|
Tomato |
Cotton |
Pepper |
Okra |
Rο
(offspring/individual) |
56.45 ±
6.17a |
55.29 ±
5.79a |
20.43 ±
2.85b |
19.81 ±
3.06b |
T (d) |
23.91 ±
0.15d |
25.71 ±
0.19c |
30.52 ±
0.25b |
32.85 ±
0.33a |
r(dˉ1) |
0.1684
± 0.0049a |
0.1558
± 0.0044a |
0.0985
± 0.0048b |
0.0905
± 0.005b |
λ(dˉ1) |
1.1834
± 0.0058a |
1.1687
± 0.0051a |
1.1035
± 0.0053b |
1.0947
± 0.0054b |
Where R0=Net reproductive rate; T=Mean generation time; r=Intrinsic rate of natural increase; λ=Finite rate of increase. Values
are mean ± S.E; Means within rows followed by the same letter are not
significantly different. Standard errors were measured by 200,000 bootstrap
resampling
Fig. 4:
Age-stage specific reproductive rate (vxj)
of B.
tabaci reared
on four host plant species
Fig. 5: Comparison of population projections for B. tabaci
reared on four host plant species, based on the age-stage, two-sex life table
Adult
pre-oviposition period (APOP), total pre-oviposition period (TPOP), and
fecundity are essential parameters in assessing the potential of an insect pest
on specific host plants (Awmack and Leather 2002; Azimi 2016). TPOP is often
preferred over APOP; it includes the influence of pre-adult developmental
duration on growth rate (Gabre et al. 2005). In present studies, APOP
and TPOP differed significantly among tested host species. Okra generated the
highest APOP and TPOP. The female fecundity of B. tabaci observed on
three host species (soybean, cowpea and garden bean) was 160.85, 153.07 and 98,
respectively (Musa and Ren 2005). Salas and Mendoza (1995) reported that the
egg incubation period of sweet-potato whitefly varied from 7.3, 4.0, 2.7, 2.5
and 5.8 for the first instar to the pupal stage, respectively. Female and male
longevities were recorded as 19.0 and 19.4 days. The female fecundity remained
high 194.9 with an 86.5% survival rate.
The population parameters present a brief idea about the
influence of host plants on the population growth rate of a pest insect. The
most crucial population parameters include the net reproductive rate (R0),
mean generation time (T), intrinsic rate of increase (r) and the finite
rate of increase (k). The higher values of the population parameters except
mean generation time exhibit a large population size (Goundoudaki et al.
2003). The significant differences in these population parameters were
demonstrated by two biotypes of B. tabaci reared on G. hirsutum L. and Brassica napus L. (Samih et al. 2014).
Musa and Ren (2005) reported that based on population parameters, rapeseed
and cotton offered slow development of B. tabaci as compared to soybean.
Kakimoto et al. (2007) presented that r and R0
values of B. argentifolii were 0.168 and 185.1; 0.153 and 130.7; 0.143
and 73.1 and 0.110 and 36.1 on eggplant, cucumber, sweet pepper, and tomato,
respectively. In present study, the population parameters were significantly
different when B. tabaci reared on alternative host plant species. The
higher net reproductive rate was observed on tomato and lower on okra. The
intrinsic rate and the finite rate of increases were found higher among tomato
and cotton as compared to other host species. Nonethless, in contradiction to
these findings, negative response of different cotton cultivars against B.
tabaci has also been reported (Chandi and Kular 2014; Azimi 2016; Pessoa et
al. 2016).
Population projection helps in
understanding any change in stage structure based on life table data (Chi 1990;
Reddy and Chi 2015). The time of stage emergence of a population can be
depicted by the concept of population projection and nowadays it is being used
in various pest management strategies (Chi 1990). In a well-structured
integrated pest management (IPM program), it is crucial to know about the
age-stage specific consumption by a pest, which helps in devising a
comprehensive pest control strategy (Huang et al. 2017). The population
projection also helps in estimating the fluctuations in the feeding potential
of the age-stage structure (Peng et al. 2016). The variability in growth
was projected using life table data from 2.5th and 97.5th
percentiles of finite rate of increase and the net reproductive rate. It was
observed that with the advancement in time, the growth rate of B. tabaci
stages was approximately equal to the intrinsic rate of increase on the natural
logarithm scale (Huang et al. 2017).
Conclusion
The application of the age-stage two-sex life table to
study the behavior of B. tabaci concerning different host plants yielded
many valuable results. Longer fecundity and population parameters were observed
on tomato specifically, with better nutritional qualities as compared to other
host plant species. In summary, it was concluded that B. tabaci has
successfully shifted to agricultural and horticultural crops and has been
developed as a significant pest. Therefore, it was concluded that tomato is the
most suitable host plant of B. tabaci, albeit, the pest also developed
successfully on other hosts like cotton, pepper and okra. It indicates that
these hosts might play an important role in the population development,
survival and overwintering of B. tabaci. Therefore, measures should be
taken at all levels to combat the attack of this pest. Moreover, the biology of
B. tabaci should also be studied using an age-stage two-sex life table
in varying environmental conditions.
Acknowledgments
Authors are thankful to the Ayub Agricultural Research
Institute, Faisalabad, for the provision of tested host plant species. Authors
are also highly indebted to Prof. Hsin Chi, Department of Entomology, National
Chung Hsing University, Taiwan, for guidance about the application of the
age-stage two-sex life table.
Author
Contributions
MF, MS designed and performed the experiment, BSK, SA and FH
supervised the experiments and reviewed the manuscript, MRS analysed the raw
data, US and MA helped in manuscript writeup.
References
Akram M, F Hafeez, M Farooq, M
Arshad, M Hussain, S Ahmed, S Zia, HAA Khan (2013). A case to study population
dynamics of Bemisia tabaci and Thrips tabaci on Bt and non-Bt cotton
genotypes. Pak J Agric Sci 50:617‒623
Awmack CS, SR Leather (2002).
Host plant quality and fecundity in herbivorous insects. Ann Rev Entomol 47:817‒844
Azimi S (2016). Effect of
Iranian Bt cotton on life table of Bemisia
tabaci (Hemiptera: Alyrodidae) and Cry 1Ab detection in the whitefly
honeydew. Arthropods 5:87‒96
Barro PJD, SS Liu, LM Boykin, AB
Dinsdale (2011). Bemisia tabaci: A statement of species status. Ann Rev Entomol 56:1‒19
Bernardi D, MS Garcia, M Botton,
DE Nava (2012). Biology and fertility life table of the green aphid Chaetosiphon
fragaefolli on strawberry cultivars. J
Ins Sci 12; Article 28
Birch L (1948). The intrinsic
rate of natural increase of an insect population. J Anim Ecol 17:15‒26
Chi H (2017). TIMING-MSChart: A computer program for the
population projection based on age-stage, two-sex life table. Retrieved from: http://140.120.197.173/ecology/prod02.htm
Chi H (1990). Timing of control based on the stage
structure of pest populations: A simulation approach. J Econ Entomol
83:1143‒1150
Chi H (1988). Life-table analysis incorporating both
sexes and variable development rates among individuals. Environ Entomol
17:26‒34
Efron B, RJ Tibshirani (1993). An Introduction to the Bootstrap.
Chapman & Hall, New York, USA
Farooq M, X Zhu, M Shakeel, A Iftikhar, MR Shahid, N
Saeed, MS Arain (2020). Comparative analysis of the demographic parameters of
seven spotted ladybird beetle (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) reared on various
host aphid species. Peer J 8; Article e8313
Farooq M, M Shakeel, A Iftikhar, MR Shahid, X Zhu
(2018). Age-stage, two-sex life tables of the lady beetle (Coleoptera:
Coccinellidae) feeding on different aphid species. J Econ Entomol 111:575‒585
Huang HW, H Chi, CL Smith (2017). Linking demography and consumption of Henosepilachna
vigintioctopunctata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) fed on Solanum
photeinocarpum (Solanales: Solanaceae): With a new method to project the
uncertainty of population growth and consumption. J Econ Entomol
111:1–9
Jones DR (2003). Plant viruses
transmitted by whiteflies. Eur J Plant
Pathol 109:195‒219
Pessoa R, GD Rossi, AC Busoli
(2016). Transgenic cotton-fed Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Hemiptera:
Aleyrodidae) affects the parasitoid Encarsia desantisi Viggiani
(Hymenoptera: Aphelinidae) Development. Neotrop
Entomol 45:102‒106
Tuan SJ, CC Lee, H Chi (2014a). Population and
damage projection of Spodoptera litura (F.) on peanuts (Arachis
hypogaea L.) under different conditions using the age‐stage, two‐sex life table. Pest Manage Sci 70:805‒813
Tuan SJ, NJ Li, CC Yeh, LC Tang,
H Chi (2014b). Effects of green manure cover crops on Spodoptera litura
(Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) populations. J
Econ Entomol 107:897‒905